Nukewatch

Working for a nuclear-free future since 1979

  • Issues
    • Direct Action
    • Environmental Justice
    • Nuclear Power
      • Chernobyl
      • Fukushima
    • Nuclear Weapons
    • On The Bright Side
    • Radiation Exposure
    • Radioactive Waste
    • Renewable Energy
    • Uranium Mining
    • US Bombs Out of Germany
  • Quarterly Newsletter
    • Quarterly Newsletter
    • Newsletter Archives
  • Resources
    • Nuclear Heartland Book
    • Fact Sheets
    • Reports, Studies & Publications
      • The New Nuclear Weapons: $1.74 Trillion for H-bomb Profiteers and Fake Cleanups
      • Nuclear Power: Dead In the Water It Poisoned
      • Thorium Fuel’s Advantages as Mythical as Thor
      • Greenpeace on Fukushima 2016
      • Drinking Water at Risk: Toxic Military Wastes Haunt Lake Superior
    • Nukewatch in the News
    • Links
    • Videos
  • About
    • About Nukewatch
    • Contact Us
  • Get Involved
    • Action Alerts!
    • Calendar
  • Donate

June 27, 2017 by Nukewatch Leave a Comment

Legal Evolution: World Welcomes Draft Treaty Ban on Nuclear Weapons

By John LaForge

Summer Quarterly 2017

The United Nations General Assembly, New York, New York.

Last March, over 130 countries joined in long-sought after negotiations for a global treaty ban on nuclear weapons, successfully fending off coercive efforts by the United States and other nuclear-armed states to de-fund and derail the campaign. On May 22, 2017, the language of a “Draft Convention on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons,” was delivered to the United Nations for final negotiations taking place from June 15 to July 7 in New York.

Notwithstanding a president who opposes the treaty and who may know less about nuclear weapons than most highschoolers, the vast majority of the world’s people welcome the draft treaty.

Last summer, Donald Trump famously asked, “If we have ‘em [nuclear weapons], why can’t we use ‘em?” although tens of thousands of citizens, along with generals, legal experts, governments, churches, religious leaders and UN resolutions have for decades been explaining exactly why.

At the National Press Club on Feb. 2, 1998, General George Butler, a former commander of US Strategic Air Command, authoritatively answered Mr. Trump: “The likely consequences of nuclear weapons have no politically, militarily or morally acceptable justification.”

Gen. Butler’s famously startling speech was informed by countless books, articles, archives and studies. His experience and reflection led him to say about H-bombs that, “The unbounded wantonness of their effects … transcend time and space, poisoning the earth and deforming its inhabitants for generation upon generation. They leave us wholly without defense, expunge all hope for meaningful survival. They hold in their sway not just the fate of nations but the very meaning of civilization.” The same year, Gen. Butler joined 60 other retired generals and admirals calling for nuclear weapons abolition.

What the military retirees have pointedly left unsaid about nuclear weapons is that their use is illegal according to their own Service Manuals. International law scholars have argued at length, some successfully, that together the manuals and the law of nations make any use of H-bombs a crime. Experts including Peter Weiss, Richard Falk, Ann Fagan Ginger, Francis Boyle, John Burroughs, and Matthew Lippman, etc., movement attorneys like Anabel Dwyer, Bill Durland, Bill Quigley, John Bachman, and Kary Love, etc., thousands of legal rights advocates from former US Attorney General Ramsey Clark and England’s George Delf, to life-long war resister Dave McReynolds, and hundreds of plowshares disarmament activists from Carl Kabat to Angie Zelter, have all made the case.

The language of the new Draft Convention is comprehensive, compelling and even awe-inspiring. It includes the legally unprecedented acknowledgement that women and girls are more seriously harmed by radiation than the rest of the population. The draft’s Preamble says in part:

“Deeply concerned about the catastrophic consequences that would result from any use of nuclear weapons and the consequent need to make every effort to ensure that nuclear weapons are never used again under any circumstances,

“Cognizant that the catastrophic consequences of nuclear weapons transcend national borders, pose grave implications for human survival, the environment, socioeconomic development, the global economy, food security and for the health of future generations, and of the disproportionate impact of ionizing radiation on maternal health and on girls, …”

“Affirming that there exists an obligation to pursue in good faith and bring to a conclusion negotiations leading to nuclear disarmament in all its aspects under strict and effective international control…”

The ban negotiations build on a long history of international treaty development that has challenged the legitimacy of nuclear weapon effects for decades without explicitly outlawing them by name.

In 1907, the Hague Regulations banned the use of poison. Radioactive fallout is poisonous to say the least. Because attacks that are “analogous to gas” warfare are banned by the 1925 Geneva Protocol, nuclear war’s effects, and consequencly any use of them, can be considered illegal. The 1945 Nuremberg Charter, written by US judges, outlaws “planning and preparation” of massacres—a monumental change in treaty law, since it implicates nuclear war planners before their weapons cause mass destruction. Indiscriminate destruction is explicitly forbidden by the 1949 Geneva Conventions.

In 1961, the UN General Assembly adopted Resolution 1653, “Recalling that the use of weapons of mass destruction, causing unnecessary human suffering, was in the past prohibited…” This early UN resolution declared in part:

“The use of nuclear and thermo-nuclear weapons is … a direct violation of the Charter of the United Nations; … would exceed even the scope of war and cause indiscriminate suffering and destruction … and, as such, is contrary to the rules of international law and to the laws of humanity; …. is a war directed not against an enemy or enemies alone but also against mankind [sic] in general, since the peoples of the world not involved in such a war will be subjected to all the evils generated by the use of such weapons; [and] Any State using nuclear and thermonuclear weapons is to be considered as … acting contrary to the laws of humanity and as committing a crime against mankind and civilization…”

In 1996, the UN’s International Court of Justice, or World Court heard arguments from UN Member States on whether the threat or use of nuclear weapons was legal. The judges concluded that “the threat of use of nuclear weapons would generally be contrary to the rules of international law…” The World Court also reminded the world that the 1968 Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) requires treaty signers to “bring to a conclusion negotiations leading to nuclear disarmament in all its aspects under strict and effective international control.”

The United Sates ratified the NPT which obligates signatories to “pursue negotiations in good faith on effective measures relating to cessation of the nuclear arms race at an early date and to nuclear disarmament.” [Emphasis added] Forty-nine years later, “an early date” has finally arrived.

New Treaty Would Ban Nuclear Weapons by Name

The Articles in the new draft treaty declare in part:

“Each State Party undertakes never under any circumstances to: Develop, produce, manufacture, otherwise acquire, possess or stockpile nuclear weapons or other nuclear explosive devices; Transfer to any recipient whatsoever nuclear weapons or other nuclear explosive devices or control over such weapons … directly, or indirectly; Receive the transfer or control over nuclear weapons or other nuclear explosive devices directly, or indirectly; Use nuclear weapons;” or test nuclear weapons.

There are eight pages of detailed rules regarding Obligations, Declarations, Safeguards, Implementation, Costs, Amendments, Disputes, Universality, Duration, Ratification, and Reservations. Dozens of contested issues remain.

Beatrice Fihn, Director of the International Campaign to Abolish Nuclear Weapons, celebrated the progress. “The release of a draft treaty to ban nuclear weapons is a milestone in the decades-long effort to ban these indiscriminate weapons of mass destruction because of their inhumane and catastrophic impacts. Once adopted, the treaty will constitute an important step toward their eventual elimination,” she said.

How about a toast!

Filed Under: Newsletter Archives, Nuclear Weapons, On The Bright Side, Quarterly Newsletter Tagged With: nuclear weapons

June 26, 2017 by Nukewatch 1 Comment

Counting Carriers, or, When is an F-35B not an aircraft?

Summer Quarterly 2017

In the post-fact US Navy, the USS America, left,  with up to 2,930 personnel and a compliment of 20 F-35B fighter jets, is not an aircraft carrier.

The Pentagon likes to say it has 10 aircraft carriers, the 10 Nimitz-class “super carriers” that displace 100,000 tons, and carry up to 6,000 people. But it actually has nineteen.

The 19 carriers are not for deterrence or defense, considering Russia, China, Brazil, India, France and Thailand each have exactly one. Italy and Spain have two each, but they’re NATO allies.

Not counted by the Pentagon are its Tarawa-class carriers with 2,800 people onboard. Three football fields long, and 20 stories high, the Tarawa ships “have the general profile of an aircraft carrier,” as the website GlobalSecurity.org notes. They carry 35 fighter aircraft, including Harrier fighter jets, Harrier jump jets, helicopters, reconnaissance aircraft and thousands of tons of langing vehicles for invasions.

The eight other giant carriers are 45,000-ton Wasp-class behemoths, known instead as “amphibious assault ships” that the Navy calls “the largest amphibious ships in the world.” They launch helicopters, jump jets, hovercraft, landing craft and assault vehicles, and carry up to 2000 Marines. Used for waging war “forward…from the sea,” and “assault by air,” each of the eight Wasps have a 600-bed hospital.

Two of the newest carriers—the $3.5 billion USS America and USS Tripoli—are “considerably larger than recent aircraft-carrying ships constructed for the Korean, Japanese, and Australian navies,” according to Robert Farley of the University of Kentucky’s Patterson School. The America-class will carry up to 20 Marine Corps F-35B fighter jets, plus Osprey tilt-rotor aircraft, and helicopter gunships.

Not satisfied with a 19-to-one advantage, the Navy is sea testing the biggest carrier on Earth, the Gerald R. Ford, a 100,000-ton, $10 billion giant that has a crew of 4,300 and carries a fleet of 90 aircraft.

—Lockheed Martin; The Diplomat, April 17, 2014; GlobalSecurity.org, “World Wide Aircraft Carriers – 2014”

Filed Under: Military Spending, Newsletter Archives, Nuclear Weapons, Quarterly Newsletter Tagged With: nuclear weapons, Pentagon, war, weapon

June 9, 2017 by Nukewatch Leave a Comment

With Ballistic Missile Defenses, There’s a Secret to Success

The corporate gravy train known as Star Wars, Ballistic Missile Defense (BMD), or just Missile Defense—after having spent over $200 billion since 1983—is finally celebrating a successful test. On May 31, 2017 the Pentagon claimed that it hit a missile shot from the Pacific with a missile shot from California.

The veracity of the claim is impossible to confirm because, as always, the military did not provide details. Actual success is highly unlikely. Since 2002, the Pentagon has been allowed to keep secret all key test information, including flight test data on all its BMD experiments. The military’s blanket classification of these testing results was imposed in the face of highly embarrassing scientific evidence of test fakery and two years after the FBI began an investigation into fraud and cover-up inside the program.

Open missile hatches on one of US Navy’s 12 Trident ballistic missile-firing submarines. Each D-5 rocket can carry up to 8 nuclear warheads and have a range of 4,600 miles. 

On June 6, Nukewatch asked Bruce Gagnon of the Global Network Against Weapon & Nuclear Power in Space if the secrecy rules are still in place. In an email Gagnon wrote: “Sure they are. Many of the tests are scripted, what [City University of New York physicist Dr.] Michio Kaku calls ‘strap down rabbit tests.’ They can’t afford to release [details]. It would sink their boat.”

Secrecy could be the only successful thing in the BMD program. It’s been savaged, by independent and government scientists for over 26 years. In 1997, Professor Gordon Mitchell of Univ. of Pittsburgh blasted “secrecy and misinformation on missile defense research,” in the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, arguing that the “shackles of secrecy and classification” should be removed so that scientific peer review could protect taxpayers from fraud. Mitchell wrote: “Given the lack of grave or immediate ballistic missile threat to the US … BMD research data should be presumptively public, not born secret.”

One program centers on a rocket known as Standard Missile 3 or SM-3, which the Pentagon claimed in 2010 had succeeded in 84% of its tests. But Dr. Theodore Postol, an MIT physicist, and George Lewis, a Cornell physicist, studied the military’s data and reported that only 10 to 20 percent of the tests worked. “The system … will intercept warheads only by accident, if ever,” Postol told the New York Times May 18, 2010.

Postol has been exposing corruption in the scandal-ridden missile industry since the 1991 US war on Iraq. Back then, he proved that not one Patriot air defense rocket stopped a Scud missile. The Pentagon had claimed then the Patriot’s success rate was 80% in Saudi Arabia and 50% in Israel.

Calling the program “delusional,” Postol, Lewis, Kaku, Mitchell, Gagnon and other long-standing critics remind taxpayers that any enemy sophisticated enough to field intercontinental ballistic missiles will produce decoys and other means confounding defenses. Laura Grego, a physicist with Union of Concerned Scientists, lampooned the Pentagon’s claim of a May 30 success, blogging that the military couldn’t honestly say that the test had actually worked unless it had evaded real countermeasures like decoy warheads.

In 2012, the National Research Council, the nation’s preeminent group of scientists, issued a 260-page report critical of the program, saying current enemy “countermeasures” make the anti-missile system unworkable. The report also called a planned $28 billion group of satellites used to track enemy warheads “unneeded.”

Time magazine nailed the military’s fundamental reason for secrecy with its July 10, 2000 headline: “Missile Impossible: This week’s $100 million test of the space shield is all but fixed.” In June that year, 53 House Democrats asked the FBI to investigate the anti-missile program for “serious allegation of fraud and cover up.” The bureau later looked into allegations that the giant military contractor TRW committed fraud and a cover-up while developing a key component of BMD system.

For a more detailed look at anti-ballistic embezzlement, ask Nukewatch for its Special Report, “Missile Defense Fraud Goes Ballistic.”  — John LaForge

Sources: Global Network, June 6, 2017; New York Times, May 31, 2017, Sept. 12, 2012, & May 18, 2010; Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, Aug. 26, 2001; Extra!, F.A.I.R., Nov. 1, 2000; Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, March 1997.

Filed Under: Newsletter Archives, Nuclear Weapons, Quarterly Newsletter, Weekly Column Tagged With: nuclear weapons, Pentagon, weapons testing

October 7, 2016 by Nukewatch Leave a Comment

Nuclear Weapons & War

nuclearblastMissile Fields Still Armed & Dangerous

By John LaForge
Reprinted from the Winter 2006 – 2007 Nukewatch Quarterly

The number of Minuteman missiles has been cut in half since 1988, when Nukewatch published Nuclear Heartland, our groundbreaking atlas of the missiles’ locations.

At the time, the Air Force was operating six giant missile fields: two in North Dakota, and one each in Missouri, South Dakota, Montana and Wyoming/Colorado/Nebraska.

Three of these missile fields have now been decommissioned and eliminated: Missouri, South Dakota and Grand Forks, ND. Interestingly, these three areas were the most active with political and nonviolent direct action protesting nuclear weapons and the suicidal nuclear war policies that persist to this day.

mushroom

In South Dakota, adjacent to the Ellsworth Air Force Base, horse rancher Marv Kammerer kept a permanent vigil against nuclear madness. Marv’s ranch was a hub of Black Hills anti-nuclear activism during the ‘80s. He placed a giant peace sign made of painted stones on his land at one end of the air force runway so the bomber pilots wouldn’t ever miss it.

In Missouri, the Silo Pruning Hooks plowshares action in 1984 brought attention to the first-strike Minuteman missiles, especially after four activists ¯ Carl and Paul Kabat, Helen Woodson and Larry Cloud Morgan ¯ received 8-to-12 years, the longest prison sentences for civil disobedience in U.S. history. Later, Nukewatch sponsored educational peace camps and participated in the Missouri Peace Planters actions that also resulted in serious prison sentences.

In Grand Forks, North Dakota, the Bemidji, Minnesota Friends for a Nonviolent World organized annual Martin Luther King birthday protests (beginning before it was a holiday), as well as Hiroshima and Nagasaki Day actions, and a 150-mile Walk for Peace from Bemidji to the Grand Forks Air Force base ¯ a walk conducted six years in a row.

In Wyoming, 50 giant MX missiles, with up to ten warheads on each rocket, have all been withdrawn from the western side of the field which is still maintained by the F.E. Warren Air Force Base “missileers.”

The missiles still in operation — with a total of 500 Minuteman intercontinental ballistic missiles (ICBM) still on “alert” status — are at Minot, North Dakota; Great Falls, Montana; and at the shared border area of Wyoming/Colorado/Nebraska. (See maps above)

Of the 10,000 warheads still deployed and stored in the U.S. nuclear arsenal, 2,346, about 24 percent, are now on 14 Trident submarines. Eight Tridents are on the East Coast at Kings Bay, Georgia, and six are on the West Coast at Bangor, Washington.

The U.S. is alone in placing its nuclear weapons in other countries; between 400 and 480 U.S. warheads are deployed at U.S. bases in England, Holland, Germany, Italy, Belgium and Turkey.

minot map copy

 

Each dot in the maps above and below pinpoints the location of one Minuteman missile. Nukewatch spent three years — 1985 through 1988 — locating the landbased missile silos of the United States. Above are the 150 Intercontinental Ballistic Missiles located in North Dakota.

montana copy

The 200 ICBMs located in Montana (above)

nebraska, colorado, wyoming

The 150 ICBMs located in the field covering the corners of Wyoming, Nebraska and Colorado

Contact us for related articles and information.

 

Filed Under: Nuclear Weapons, War Tagged With: nuclear weapons, war

  • « Previous Page
  • 1
  • 2

Stay Connected

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Subscribe

Donate

Categories

  • B61 Bombs in Europe
  • Chernobyl
  • Counterfeit Reactor Parts
  • Depleted Uranium
  • Direct Action
  • Environment
  • Environmental Justice
  • Fukushima
  • Lake Superior Barrels
  • Military Spending
  • Newsletter Archives
  • North Korea
  • Nuclear Power
  • Nuclear Weapons
  • Office News
  • On The Bright Side
  • Photo Gallery
  • Protect the Water Close Xcel's Monticello Reactor
  • Quarterly Newsletter
  • Radiation Exposure
  • Radioactive Waste
  • Renewable Energy
  • Social Issues
  • Sulfide Mining
  • Through the Prism of Nonviolence
  • Uncategorized
  • Uranium Mining
  • US Bombs Out of Germany
  • War
  • Weekly Column

Contact Us

(715) 472-4185
nukewatch1@lakeland.ws

Address:
740A Round Lake Road
Luck, Wisconsin 54853
USA

Donate To Nukewatch

News & Information on Nuclear Weapons,
Power, Waste & Nonviolent Resistance

Stay Connected

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

© 2026 · Nukewatch